Records
What Should I Record in My Forest Garden, and How Often?
A trial of ten UK forest gardens found that its participants stopped keeping records after about three years. Here is a suggested lightweight routine, with a copyable template and a photo method.
Updated November 17, 2026 · 7 min read
The hard part of forest garden records is not starting but still doing it in year four. This article proposes a small routine: a handful of fields per plant, a few fixed dates in the year, and a photo method that makes your pictures comparable. Then it explains how to read the result after one season and after several.
Why a record routine has to be small
The Permaculture Association ran a Ten Year Forest Garden Trial in the UK. In its Year 5 report (Silvio Volkmann, October 2016), the author says the trial's participants stopped keeping records after three years. Section 3.3 says they did so "due to lack of time and a clear guidance regarding What and How".
A few details from the same report are worth keeping in proportion. The report rests mainly on seven telephone interviews held at the end of 2015, and its author says it is not appropriate to draw scientifically accurate conclusions from the survey. So this is one small group's account of why recording lapsed, not a law. It is still a useful warning, because the two reasons given are ones most of us would recognise.
In section 5.1 the report says the participants saw two major issues, the lack of time and a lack of knowledge, which they describe as the lack of very clear guidance, and adds that the second is more important than the first. It also says the easiest thing is just to take photographs, but that photos too need a structure (subjects, weather, seasons and others) to be comparable. In its list of possible guidelines for participatory research, the report names three headings: What (the measurement), When (the dates of taking records) and How (a guide for laymen).
Below is our attempt to answer those three headings for one owner with a phone and a notebook. The fields, dates and photo steps are our suggestions, not the trial's.
What: five fields per plant
Keep the per-plant record short enough to fill in standing next to the plant in a couple of minutes.
- ID: a short code that never changes (for example A-07 for the seventh plant in area A), written on a tag and on your sketch map. If a plant dies and you replant, give the new plant a new ID and keep the old record.
- Name: the species and, if you know it, the variety, written the same way every time.
- Planted: the date, where it came from, and the position (area and a note such as 'south of the pond, under the plum').
- Condition: one word from a short list you choose once, for example thriving, ok, struggling, dead, replaced. Keep the list to five words or fewer so that entries stay comparable between years.
- Note: one line on what you actually saw (flowers, fruit, pruning done, pest damage, what you harvested). A rough amount is fine if you say which unit you used, such as 'one small bowl' or 'about half a bucket'.
Leave out anything you would not realistically fill in twice. Soil tests and biodiversity counts are a larger job than a routine record. Start with the five fields and add one more only after a full year of keeping them up.
When: four fixed visits and the days that matter
Put fixed moments in your calendar rather than recording whenever you remember. A sensible minimum is one visit per season: late winter, spring, midsummer and autumn, adjusted to your climate. Choose dates that match when things happen where you live, and check with a local extension office or growers' group if unsure.
- On planting day: fill in ID, name and planted, and take the first photo. It is the one visit you cannot redo later.
- At each seasonal visit: update condition, add one line to the note, and take the standard photos described below.
- After a notable event: a frost, a storm, a drought spell, a pest outbreak, a big pruning job. A single line with the date is enough.
- At harvest: a note of what came off which plant and roughly how much, if you want yield information at all. The Year 5 report says yields were mostly not monitored quantitatively; a rough record is better than memory.
If you can only manage two visits, keep the two where most changes happen, and note which ones you missed.
How: a photo routine that makes pictures comparable
The report describes photographs as the easiest record, and says they still need structure. These steps are our suggestion for adding that structure.
- Choose the viewpoints once. For each area, pick a fixed standing spot, for example beside a gatepost or a stake you have driven in, and photograph the same direction every time. Mark the spot so you can find it again.
- Keep the framing the same. Same spot, same direction, same zoom, same orientation of the phone. If you can include a permanent landmark such as a fence post, do.
- Take one wide shot per viewpoint and one close shot per tracked plant, with its tag in the frame.
- Date every photo, and write the date and ID in your notebook too, in case files get moved.
- Note the weather in a few words ('overcast, after rain') since the report lists weather alongside subjects and seasons as things that photos need in order to be comparable.
A copyable template
Copy this into a notebook with one page per area, or into a spreadsheet with one row per plant per visit.
- Plant sheet (once per plant): ID | Name | Planted (date) | Source | Position | Replaced by (ID, if any)
- Visit sheet (one row per plant per visit): Date | ID | Condition (one word) | Note (one line) | Amount, with unit (harvest visits only) | Photo taken (yes or no)
- Area sheet (one row per viewpoint per visit): Date | Viewpoint name | Weather in a few words | Photo taken (yes or no)
Illustration only: all numbers invented. A garden with 30 tracked plants and four visits a year gives 120 visit rows, at roughly one minute each. That is about two hours of writing a year, plus photos. If that is too much, track fewer plants, not fewer visits.
Reading the records after one season
One year gives a baseline, not a trend. Use it for three things.
- Find your losses. Sort the visit sheet by Condition and list every plant marked struggling or dead. Check the position field for a shared spot.
- Flip through the four photos from each viewpoint in date order. The point is to see what changed across the season at a glance.
- Check the notebook itself. If half the visits are blank, the routine is too heavy. Cut it down now.
Do not treat one season as typical. Use your event notes to list possible explanations worth checking; the records alone cannot tell you why a plant did poorly.
Reading the records after several seasons
Later years let you compare the same plant and the same viewpoint across seasons.
- Same viewpoint, same month, different years: lay the photos side by side. Growth, shade, ground cover and gaps are easier to judge this way than from memory. This is also why the framing rules matter.
- Condition over time: a plant that is ok in year one and struggling in years two and three is a different case from one that was struggling from the start. Check the position and event notes for a shared cause.
- Replacements: count what you replaced and where. A repeat pattern may point to a site problem rather than bad luck.
- Harvest notes: you will not have precise yields, but you can see which plants gave something in which years.
- Handover: section 4.2.2 of the report says that at several sites the owners or main managers changed during the trial, which indicates the need for contingency planning. Our own view is that a plain record with IDs and a map also helps whoever takes over.
If you do only one thing from this article, photograph fixed viewpoints on the same dates each year.
For the first-year version of this, from nursery receipt onwards, see our piece on a fruit tree record. For turning the IDs into a map, see how to map a food forest you already have. For scouting problems on a visit, see our tree health scouting log, and for harvest detail, our per-tree harvest records.
Paper first, an app if you want it
A notebook, a spreadsheet and a folder of dated photos are all you need, and the routine works the same on paper. If you would rather see your trees on a map with the photos and notes attached to each one on your iPhone, CanopyTwin does that, with a 30-day free trial. It is a convenience, not a requirement.
Turn your orchard into a digital twin
CanopyTwin does the survey-to-map pipeline for you — QR tree tags, a live satellite map, and AI fruit counts from your photos. Start free, no card required.
Keep reading
- How to Map a Food Forest You Already Have (Tree by Tree, With a Phone)8 min →
- A Fruit Tree Record From Nursery Receipt to First Harvest7 min →
- How to Keep Per-Tree Harvest Records: A Copyable Sheet for Pawpaw, Persimmon, Nut and Backyard Orchards8 min →
- Keeping a Tree Health and Disease Scouting Log7 min →