Identification
Soursop vs Cherimoya vs Sugar Apple Leaves: Telling Annonas Apart
Soursop, cherimoya, sugar apple and custard apple are close relatives with similar simple leaves. Gloss, hairs, leaf drop and the smell of a crushed leaf sort most of them, and hybrids explain the rest.
Updated November 19, 2026 · 8 min read
Why young Annonas get mixed up
Soursop, cherimoya, sugar apple (sweetsop) and custard apple (bullock's heart, Annona reticulata) all belong to the genus Annona in the family Annonaceae. Nurseries sell them as small unlabeled plants, common names are used loosely, and the fruit that would settle the question is years away. Even the names overlap. One Purdue reference notes that "custard apple" has been widely misapplied to other species and to the atemoya hybrid, and that "cherimoya" is sometimes misapplied to the custard apple.
The leaves are the best evidence you have in the first few years, and they differ in more than size.
First, confirm it is an Annona
Botanical descriptions of the genus agree on a short checklist. Look for leaves that are simple (one undivided blade), with smooth edges, arranged alternately along the twig in two rows, and with veins that are prominent on the underside. Twigs are often zigzag, and some species have rusty or reddish hairs on young branchlets, stalks or leaves.
- One blade per stalk, not a leaf divided into leaflets.
- Leaves alternate, not paired opposite each other, and held in two rows along the twig.
- Smooth, untoothed margin.
- Short leaf stalks, sometimes with fine hairs.
That description fits many tropical trees, so treat it as a way to narrow the field, not as proof. Confirm with the species checks below and, later, flowers and fruit.
What to look at on each leaf
- Surface and gloss: smooth and glossy, dull, or covered in fine hairs. Run a fingertip over the top and the underside.
- Underside: pale, bloomy, or velvety.
- Size and shape: lay a mature leaf on a ruler. Ranges overlap, so use size as a supporting clue only.
- Evergreen or deciduous: does the tree drop most of its leaves in the cool or dry season?
- Smell of a crushed leaf: some Annona leaves smell unpleasant, others aromatic. Crush one leaf and smell it, keep it away from your eyes, wash your hands afterwards, and never taste it.
- Young twigs: rusty-hairy, or smooth.
- New growth: compare mature leaves from the middle of a branch, not the first flush.
Soursop (Annona muricata)
Soursop leaves are glossy and smooth. Purdue's description gives smooth, glossy, dark green leaves on the upper surface and lighter beneath, oblong, elliptic or narrowly obovate, pointed at both ends, roughly 6 to 20 centimeters long and 2.5 to 6 centimeters wide. The leaves are described as malodorous, so a crushed soursop leaf smells unpleasant rather than pleasant, and the tree is normally evergreen. Young branchlets are rusty-hairy. The tree is low-branching and bushy but slender because the limbs turn upward.
Purdue calls soursop truly tropical, with young trees in exposed places killed by only a few degrees of frost. One caution from the same source: selections differ in foliage color, and one Cuban clone is described as distinctly bluish-green, so do not rely on the shade of green.
Cherimoya (Annona cherimola)
Cherimoya is the hairy one. The leaves are alternate and two-ranked, ovate to elliptic with a short blunt point, slightly hairy on the upper surface and velvety on the underside, about 7.5 to 15 centimeters long and 3.8 to 9 centimeters wide. The leaf stalks are minutely hairy and short, and young branchlets are rusty-hairy. Growers in California describe the leaves as dark green above and velvety green below, with prominent veins and new growth that is recurved like a fiddle-neck.
Cherimoya is briefly deciduous, losing its leaves just before spring flowering, and it is a subtropical, mild-temperate tree that does not succeed in the lowland tropics. A velvety underside points to cherimoya. A brief leaf drop just before spring flowering supports it, but drought and climate also make Annonas drop leaves, so do not lean on timing alone. Some named cultivars are described as having wavy or twisted leaves, so a few odd leaves are not alarming.
One further detail from a California Rare Fruit Growers description: the axillary buds on cherimoya are hidden beneath the fleshy leaf stalks. Treat it as a detail to look at, not a deciding feature, because the sources checked for this article do not say how the other species compare.
Sugar apple or sweetsop (Annona squamosa)
Sugar apple leaves are thinner and duller. Both Purdue and University of Florida extension describe them as lanceolate to oblong, with a dull green upper side and a pale underside with a bloom (a faint waxy film). They are slightly hairy when young and smooth at maturity. They tend to run smaller: Purdue gives about 5 to 15 centimeters long, while the Florida publication gives 6.4 to 10.2 centimeters, so quote a range rather than a number. The crushed leaf is aromatic. Twigs are somewhat zigzag, the crown is open with irregular branches, and the tree is deciduous.
Custard apple or bullock's heart (Annona reticulata)
Custard apple has long, narrow leaves, described by Purdue as oblong or narrowly lanceolate, roughly 10 to 20 centimeters long and 2 to 5 centimeters wide, with conspicuous veins. They are called ill-smelling, deciduous and alternate. In southern Florida the leaves are shed at the first onset of cold weather and the tree stays dormant all winter. The tree is erect with a rounded or spreading crown.
Handle with care: the same source says sap from cut branches is acrid and irritant and can severely injure the eyes. Do not cut or snap twigs to test a plant, and wash your hands after pruning. In this genus, the leaves, seeds and sap are not for tasting.
Atemoya and other hybrids
Atemoya is a hybrid of sugar apple and cherimoya (Annona squamosa x A. cherimola, in either direction). Purdue says the tree closely resembles the cherimoya, with alternate, elliptical, leathery, deciduous leaves that are less hairy than the cherimoya's and up to 15 centimeters long. The Florida publication gives 10 to 20 centimeters, so sizes differ between sources. It describes atemoya leaves as hairy when young, smooth when mature, and variable in shape on the same tree, with the tree semi-deciduous. In practice, a tree whose leaves sit between cherimoya (velvety) and sugar apple (thin, dull, smooth at maturity) may be an atemoya, or a seedling. The Florida source adds that atemoya trees grown from seed are extremely variable, so a seedling of an atemoya is not a safe guide to its parent.
Side-by-side key
- Glossy, smooth, dark green leaves that smell unpleasant when crushed, on a tree that stays evergreen: soursop.
- Velvety underside and hairy young twigs: cherimoya. Its brief leaf drop before spring flowering is a supporting clue only, since leaf drop also depends on climate and stress.
- Thin, dull leaves with a pale bloomy underside, aromatic when crushed, deciduous: sugar apple.
- Long, narrow leaves with conspicuous veins, ill-smelling, shed in the cool season: custard apple.
- In between cherimoya and sugar apple, with variable leaves on one tree: possibly atemoya.
Where this goes wrong
- Seedlings. Purdue describes a wide range of forms among seedling soursops, and atemoya seedlings are described as extremely variable. A single leaf does not settle it.
- Rootstocks. Grafted Annonas are often on another Annona. Purdue notes that custard apple seedlings are frequently used as rootstocks for soursop, sugar apple and atemoya, and that atemoya is usually grafted onto custard apple or sugar apple. If a shoot grows from below the graft union, compare its leaves with the rest of the tree before treating it as the variety you bought.
- Misapplied names. A label that says "custard apple" or "cherimoya" may mean a different species, so check the leaf, not the tag.
- Seasonal state. A deciduous species in its dormant season has no leaves to judge. Wait for the new flush and compare mature leaves.
- Stress. Florida extension lists leaf tip death, browning and leaf drop as symptoms of salt stress in sugar apple and atemoya, and says drought makes them shed leaves. Judge identity from healthy leaves.
Photographing an Annona leaf for an ID
Photograph one mature leaf flat against a plain background, top side up, then the underside, and a branch tip showing the leaf arrangement and any hairs on the twig. Add a close-up of the underside in raking light, because velvety versus smooth is the clue photos often lose. If flowers or fruit appear, photograph those separately.
You can run these photos through our free identifier at canopytwin.com/tools/plant-id, with no account and no app. It runs on Pl@ntNet and returns ranked species matches with a score, and that score is the network's own confidence. Treat a top match as a good hypothesis, and for close relatives like these, confirm it against the leaf features above. For tropical fruit trees specifically there is also canopytwin.com/tools/plant-id/tropical-fruit-tree-identifier.
Glossy and unpleasant-smelling: soursop. Velvety underside: cherimoya. Thin, dull, aromatic: sugar apple. Long, narrow, deciduous: custard apple. In between: possibly atemoya. Confirm with flowers or fruit.
Record it once, correctly
An Annona planting is easy to mislabel: tags fade, the names overlap, and the cold tolerance and leaf drop that differ between these species mean the wrong label leads to the wrong care. Once you have a confident identification, log the species against that individual tree. CanopyTwin keeps each tree on a map with photos and notes attached to that tree, on iPhone. It is a convenience, not a requirement, and it comes with a 30-day free trial.
Turn your orchard into a digital twin
CanopyTwin does the survey-to-map pipeline for you — QR tree tags, a live satellite map, and AI fruit counts from your photos. Start free, no card required.